VR Boxing Game "Knockout League" Review

This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →

Put simply, Knockout League is a boxing-themed action game. While there are several other VR games out there that fall into the boxing simulator category, this game sets itself apart and plays completely differently.

Looking at the Steam reviews, that difference is the source of a fair bit of mixed opinion. So in this post, I'll clarify that aspect while touching on what makes the game unique.

The basic actions in this game come down to just two things: dodge and punch. The flow of a match goes like this: you dodge your opponent's incoming attack, which creates an opening, and then you counterattack in that window. Sound familiar? It's classic arcade action-game design.

Put the other way around, as a boxing simulator it completely falls apart. Even if you throw punches on your own initiative, they almost never land. The only time you can deal damage is right after dodging an opponent's attack—something that would never make sense in real boxing. That said, it genuinely captures the fun of classic action games, so whether it clicks comes down to taste—or rather, what you were expecting when you bought it.

Another defining feature of this game is its charming, colorful, pop-art characters.

Your opponents start off as tough-looking boxers, but soon enough anything goes: an octopus, a mad scientist, a pirate captain, and more. An iron maiden even shows up eventually. There's no way any of this turns into a normal boxing match.

Each character's attack animations are really well crafted and bring out their personality. They lean heavily into cartoony, comic-book flair—fists catching fire, tornadoes spinning up, and so on. Combined with the visceral scale of VR, that spectacle alone makes it well worth playing.


On the flip side, what doesn't work well is, without question, how vague the attack and dodge hitboxes feel. In a 2D action game, for instance, both enemy attacks and your own hitbox are crystal clear, because the entire view of both your character and the incoming attack fits right on the screen.

Now imagine doing that from a first-person perspective in VR. How many people can accurately track the trajectory of a fist flying straight at their face? Better yet, very few people can tell with certainty whether their own body (or more precisely, their head) actually cleared the attack.

When you're actually playing, it happens all the time that you can't tell at a glance where an opponent's attack is aimed—and if you don't know where it's going, you don't know which way to dodge. On top of that, it's hard to tell how far you need to move for a dodge to count. Often you think you dodged, only to get clipped anyway. As a result, you end up making wildly exaggerated dodging motions, which is exhausting.

f:id:kazasiki:20200814223241j:plain:w300
Dodging an attack
f:id:kazasiki:20200814222524j:plain:w400
Landing a punch

To sum it up, it's not a boxing simulator, but it's a boxing game with a distinct charm of its own. At the same time, cramming classic action-game mechanics into first-person VR introduces real frustrations, and from a UI standpoint it still feels like it could use polish.

It's enough of a workout to leave you drenched in sweat, so if you're looking for exercise, give it a shot. Just remember to take breaks between bouts.


Postscript / Bonus Notes:

I skipped over it in the main review, but the game also has a guard move—and if you time it right, a "perfect block" (just guard). It's a slightly finicky mechanic so I left out the explanation, just something to keep in mind if you play. (Though part of me can't help thinking: what is a "just guard" even doing in a boxing game?)

People say this game was inspired by NES/Famicom's Punch-Out!!, though I'm embarrassed to admit I've never actually played it myself.