Designing Melee Combat in VR Games

This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →

These are just some casual thoughts from a VR gamer. I'm not involved in VR game development at all, so please take this as just one player's perspective.

Whether it's a boxing sim or a sword-fighting action game, VR games with melee combat share a few common challenges.

First, the player has no real sense of physical impact.

When you punch an enemy, for instance, you can't naturally tell whether your blow actually landed, or whether it was a clean hit or just a grazing blow. Information that you'd normally feel through touch has to be communicated clearly through hit effects and audio cues. The same goes for getting hit yourself—except that's even harder to read.

Take a boxing simulation as an example. When you throw a punch at an opponent, the spot you're hitting is usually right inside your field of view. Since you're looking straight at the point of impact, the game can easily show hit effects to confirm contact.

Now flip it around: what happens when the enemy punches you? Usually, you aren't staring right at the spot getting hit. If you take a body blow to the stomach, you aren't looking down at your own torso—and if it's your face, you can't see it at all. On top of that, in first-person games generally (not just VR), it's tough to judge your own hitbox, making things even muddier. You constantly run into moments where you thought you dodged, only for the game to count it as a hit.

One straightforward way to solve this is simply not to design combat around dodging enemy strikes by a hair's breadth. For example, you can boil incoming attacks down to four broad zones—left/right to the head, left/right to the body—and require the player to block them. Put your hands in the right guard position to block, and pop up a shield-like visual effect whenever your block connects.

On the other hand, if you do want players to dodge, you need big, telegraphed wind-up animations or slower projectiles/strikes so they have generous room to get out of the way. The issue of unclear hitboxes doesn't disappear completely, yet it feels much fairer to the player. It might sacrifice realism, sure, but delivering a frustration-free game experience is just as important.

For example, "Knockout League" keeps attacks simplified into clear high/low/left/right patterns that are easy to block, and whenever you're meant to dodge, there's always an unmistakable wind-up. "Serious Sam VR: The Last Hope" doesn't have blocking at all, yet enemy ranged shots move slowly enough that you can cleanly dodge them.

The second major problem is that weapon weight doesn't carry over into your hands.

In VR, you can wield all sorts of weapons, yet in reality you're just holding lightweight controllers. Picture a massive greatsword: in real life, even a grown adult would struggle to swing it, whereas in VR you can whip it around effortlessly with one hand. Worse still, a real sword stops when it bites into a target, while a VR sword passes straight through. Right out of the gate, "realistic melee combat" is basically impossible.

"BONEWORKS" offers a solid answer to this problem. Put simply, it limits heavier weapons so they can only move slowly in-game. Even though your physical controller moves freely regardless of weight, the virtual weapon lags behind according to its mass—creating a mismatch between your real hands and your VR hands. It feels deeply uncanny at first, though you get used to it after a while.

Thanks to that, weapon choice actually matters: you grab a small knife for fast, lunging enemies like dogs, and break out a sledgehammer for slower human foes. It also lets you move heavy weapons faster when gripping them with both hands, so players naturally end up two-handing heavy gear.

And if you aren't aiming for "realistic melee combat" in the first place, plenty of other approaches open up. You could go for a semi-turn-based rhythm like the iOS classic Infinity Blade, where you defend against a flurry of strikes and counterattack once the enemy leaves an opening. Or you can skip blocking and dodging altogether and focus on crowd control—keeping your distance, avoiding getting surrounded, and picking enemies off one by one. With designs like those, waving a greatsword around like a feather doesn't break the game at all.

When people hear "VR," it's easy to imagine you can do anything, yet in practice there are plenty of physical constraints that call for clever workarounds. After playing a ton of VR games, I feel like I've picked up enough observations (?) to talk about them, so I'd like to write more pieces like this when the mood strikes.