Online Concert Video Quality Isn't Very Good

This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →

Table of Contents

The other day, I watched VTuber Suou Patra's solo concert livestream.

The concert itself was amazing quality and super fun, though one thing that bothered me a bit was that, honestly, the video quality wasn't great.

Given today's internet bandwidth realities it can't be helped, and neither the organizers nor SPWN (the streaming platform) are to blame at all, but it's also true that paying money to watch content and getting poor image quality feels subtly disappointing.

So I did a little quick research on video quality and bitrates across major streaming platforms.

Bitrates on Major Streaming Platforms

Here are the bitrate numbers for the major streaming platforms. These are for what is probably the most common format, 1080p 30fps SDR. For reference, I also included YouTube's upload bitrate. Since that's for uploaded video rather than a livestream, it's naturally the highest.

Platform Bitrate Source
SPWN 5.5Mbps Here
YouTube Live 3.0~6.0Mbps Here
Twitch 4.5Mbps Here
YouTube (Upload) 8Mbps Here

Yeah, that's pretty much what you'd expect. Before even comparing individual services, this seems to be roughly the practical limit of current internet connections. Some individuals might be able to reliably receive higher bitrates, but conversely, it's not hard to imagine that pushing the bitrate any higher would prevent quite a few people from watching smoothly.

You can judge the actual video quality yourself from the YouTube video linked in the tweet at the top, and my impression was: pretty clean overall, though encoding artifacts are fairly noticeable.

The reason even YouTube's uploaded videos top out around 8Mbps is probably the judgment that, even when not live, buffering/wait times hurt the user experience.

What Users Can Do

For now, the only thing users can do about this issue (?) is buy the Blu-ray disc that will presumably be released. With a Blu-ray disc, you don't have to worry about internet speed. Even though Blu-ray discs have capacity limits of their own, you'll generally get a cleaner picture than on any major streaming platform.

What Organizers and Streaming Platforms Could Potentially Do

Organizers and streaming platforms could probably do a bit more on their end.

Since everyone's connection differs, adding an option to stream at a higher bitrate is one possible approach. Of course, there are concerns like whether the platform's infrastructure can handle it and whether users will choose the right option. Still, YouTube Live already offers 1080p60fps options, so it seems well worth considering. Personally, I'd love for them to consider a higher-bitrate streaming option while keeping 1080p30fps.

Also, once the livestream has ended, it should be possible to offer a high-quality video download. I mean, if they can release a Blu-ray disc, that means the organizers at least have high-quality footage stored—so it should be possible to sell it in a downloadable format instead of only on Blu-ray.

That said, I imagine there's also a business consideration along the lines of we want fans who care about high video quality to buy the higher-priced Blu-ray disc, so it's probably tough. On top of that, current downloadable distribution platforms don't really support super high bitrates either, and the trend of steering people who want top picture quality toward Blu-ray discs isn't unique to online concerts—it's the same for movies and TV dramas too.

Summary

To sum up, compared to Blu-ray discs or uploaded videos, the video quality of livestreamed online concerts isn't very good. If you want to watch in higher quality, buy the Blu-ray disc.

(Pre-orders for the Blu-ray of the concert I mentioned at the start closed yesterday... Missed it. Actually, I did pre-order it.)