I Think Long Working Hours Are "Unsportsmanlike"

This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →

With the Dentsu controversy last year and a recent article making the rounds, I wanted to write down my personal thoughts on long working hours.

http://www.tokyo-np.co.jp/article/politics/list/201702/CK2017021502000124.htmlwww.tokyo-np.co.jp

First off, Japan's current Labor Standards Act is essentially designed to protect workers from employers. Because of that, discussions around overwork usually hold management responsible, and debates over long working hours tend to stay within that framing. That makes sense on its own terms.

At the same time, a capitalist society like Japan is built on competition and making money even at the individual level. The desire to work as much as possible to win the race, earn more profit, or gain social recognition runs deep in individuals too. Some people genuinely enjoy working. Even without a boss ordering them to, there will always be a certain number of people who want to put in huge hours.

So, should those people be allowed to work endless hours however they please? Personally, I don't think so. If it were just a matter of them working themselves to death, that would be their own business—but in a competitive society, their hours affect people who don't want to work long hours. As long as you have to turn a profit to put food on the table, competitors feel pressure to match or exceed those hours. You can't just ignore that.

You might say "well, isn't that fine?"—except long working hours are well known to cause serious health harm. Put bluntly, people die from overwork. If letting workers compete completely unchecked causes the workforce to burn out and die off, society stops functioning. That's why competition needs sensible rules. Even if the Labor Standards Act wasn't written with this specific rationale in mind, it serves as a reasonable guardrail in that sense too (honestly, it could stand to be even stricter).

Think about doping in the Olympics or pro baseball. Doping means using drugs or other substances to enhance physical performance, and it's banned today. There are several reasons, but the biggest one is the health damage to athletes. Even if doping made sports more exciting to watch, harming athletes' bodies threatens the sustainability of the entire sport. Even in free competition, limits are necessary—even when they restrict an individual's rights or choices.

Even if someone can handle long working hours, gets great results from them, and enjoys it, doesn't it still go against sportsmanship? At the end of the day, it feels like behavior that wrecks the whole field.

Of course, everything I just wrote is idealistic talk, and in practice I still end up working long hours from time to time. Still, I keep three personal rules when it comes to people who get ahead through extreme overwork: first, don't admire them; second, don't model yourself after them; third, don't compete with them. Put simply, don't recognize them as legitimate players. It's a simple rule of thumb, yet keeping just that in mind makes things a lot easier mentally.

Taken to the extreme, there are probably people out there thinking, "Who cares about the industry! If I work myself to the bone for ten years, I'll have enough money to play for the rest of my life!"—and then literally working themselves into an early grave. Let's all just take it steady around 40 hours a week.