Trying PayPay and Comparing It with PASMO

This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →

Table of Contents

Now that the cashless payment boom (?) has settled down a bit, I finally started using PayPay recently.

Normally I stick almost exclusively to IC card payments with PASMO. That was a deliberate choice on my part too, after weighing a few things, but lately more and more stores only accept PayPay, so I decided to take the plunge and set it up. Comparing those two might seem a bit odd, yet I figured I'd ramble a little about my thinking behind them and how things have changed.

Why I Was Using PASMO

The whole reason I started using PASMO in the first place was because I used to live along the Seibu Line, and when I went to get a commuter pass, PASMO was the only option. Even so, I wouldn't say I used PASMO's IC card payment in everyday shopping back then. As I recall, until a few years ago, only a pretty limited number of stores supported it.

When the government kicked off its cashless payment promotion campaign, a huge number of shops adopted IC card and QR code payments. Around that time, I started using PASMO's IC card payment all the time. Any store that accepts IC card payments, I'm pretty sure I always pay that way.

Topping it up has never really felt like a chore—I treat charging my IC card the same way I'd withdraw cash from a bank account to put in my wallet. Incidentally, PASMO has a 20,000 yen balance limit. That's a bit on the low side, though as an amount to carry around in a wallet, it feels just right. Whenever I'm buying something over 20,000 yen, I just use a credit card. Intuitively, anywhere you're making a big (?) purchase like that definitely takes credit cards anyway. So honestly, getting by with PASMO and a credit card causes almost zero inconvenience.

The reason I held off on QR code payments for so long was basically that I felt uneasy linking a credit card or bank account to them. There was the whole 7pay incident, and more recently the Docomo Kouza incident too. Because of that, topping up with cash at a physical terminal feels the safest to me. The catch is that if you do it that way, there's barely any advantage over PASMO. Sure, you earn various reward points, but I'm not the type to jump blindly at perks like that, and in my mind, the risks I just mentioned far outweigh the benefits.

Why I Started Using PayPay

This was obvious from the start, of course, yet PayPay is accepted at more places than PASMO. Around my neighborhood, that's especially noticeable at small eateries like bakeries and ramen shops. IC card payments inevitably require the shop to have an IC card reader and a constant internet connection. With QR code payments, all they really need (probably) is to set out a QR code stand. Looking at it from the merchant's perspective, it's obvious why QR code payment adoption grows faster.

Plus, as opportunities to pay with PASMO grew, using cash started feeling comparatively tedious—so I figured if PASMO and PayPay together could cover my entire regular stomping ground, all the better. Also, after looking into it, I learned you can top up PayPay at 7-Eleven ATMs, which meant I could use it with peace of mind. And among QR code payment services, PayPay seemed to have the widest merchant acceptance, so I went with PayPay.

Comparing PASMO and PayPay, and How I Split Them

Basically, I use both PASMO and PayPay. Where PASMO is accepted, I use PASMO; where PASMO isn't accepted but PayPay is, I use PayPay. And if neither works, cash. You might wonder why I don't just use PayPay for everything, right? Well, even if it's not quite as annoying as cash, using PayPay is actually pretty cumbersome. Pulling out your smartphone, launching the app, and tapping through it is a hassle, and honestly the app takes quite a while to boot up sometimes. With PASMO, you just pull out the card and tap it—PASMO is way easier.

It's basically the flip side of the store's perspective: instead of requiring equipment from the merchant, QR code payments require equipment (?) from the user—a smartphone with the app installed and an internet connection. So naturally, if your phone battery dies or you run out of mobile data and get throttled, you can't pay. At the end of the day, it's just a question of whether the store takes on the trouble or the user does.

To begin with, there are also quite a few retail shops that only support IC card payments and don't take QR code payments. Stores that already adopted IC card readers before QR code payments got popular probably don't see a reason to go out of their way to add QR. Most vending machines take IC cards too, while almost none support QR codes.

Personal Thoughts

To be honest, I don't really picture QR code payments becoming universally dominant. Even now I don't see all that many people using them, and I still think they're kind of a pain on the user side. Right now QR code payment providers are burning money at a loss to expand merchant coverage and user numbers, and it seems natural that at some point, once user growth hits a wall, things will fizzle out.

If there is a path to survival, it's probably integrating the kind of coupon and loyalty point programs that individual shops run right into the payment app. Because QR code services put an app directly in users' hands, they work well as a platform for delivering coupons and loyalty points. That would be especially welcome for small retailers that lack the resources or infrastructure to build something like that on their own. Since QR code payment companies ran massive cashback campaigns right after launch, if they can keep appealing to customers with "you save money using this," they'll be able to win more users. There's obviously a limit to how long the platforms can keep funding cashback out of their own budgets, whereas coupon campaigns run by the shops themselves can keep going sustainably, since each shop can make the math work internally.

In fact, it looks like PayPay just launched a coupon service very recently.

Launch of "PayPay Coupons" for Automatic Savings Simply by Claiming a Coupon - Press Release「クーポン取得で自動的にお得になる「PayPayクーポン」の提供を開始」に関する詳細情報を掲載しています。PayPay株式会社 · about.paypay.ne.jp

IC card payments pitching sleekness and effortless convenience versus QR code payments pitching savings and deals—it'll be interesting to see which one comes out on top.