On YouTube Music's Poor Audio Quality
This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →
Table of Contents
As I mentioned on this blog before, it's been a while since I migrated from Google Play Music to YouTube Music.
That said, since I mainly use Spotify now, I honestly barely used YouTube Music at all. However, just recently, it finally became possible to sort my uploaded tracks by the order they were added.
You can finally sort YouTube Music Uploads by Recently Added!! pic.twitter.com/FjFSZnbvr8
— kazasiki (@kazasiki) October 29, 2020
Thinking "Maybe it's actually usable now?", I tried using it properly for a short while. And then I noticed something: listening to YouTube Music in a browser sounds noticeably terrible.
YouTube Music's Audio Quality Is Bad
Here is a summary of the audio quality (bitrate) of Google Play Music vs. YouTube Music, in kbps.
| Google Play Music Free | YouTube Music Free | YouTube Music Premium | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Streaming | 320 | 128 | 256 |
| Download | 320 | 256 | 256 |
First of all, this means some kind of compression was applied when migrating from Google Play Music to YouTube Music. On top of that, on a free YouTube Music account, you can only select up to "Normal" streaming quality, capping it at 128 kbps.
Even more surprisingly, since the recommended audio bitrate for regular YouTube (the video site) is 384 kbps, even tracks originally from YouTube are getting compressed further. If you want to listen to audio (and videos) uploaded to YouTube at the highest possible quality, the best way is regular YouTube—not YouTube Music.
Personally, I don't notice much difference between Google Play Music's 320 kbps and YouTube Music's 256 kbps. It does make me a bit sad that 320 kbps streaming, which used to be free on Google Play Music, was quietly turned into a paid Premium feature, though servers aren't free either so I guess it can't be helped.
I found what seems to be an official statement from YouTube Music, so I'll link it here.
To summarize roughly:
- They do this to balance audio quality and data usage.
- High streaming audio quality is intentionally gated behind the paid tier.
- Although the bitrate dropped from 320 kbps to 256 kbps, the perceived audio quality is equivalent.
- There are no plans to offer a bitrate higher than 256 kbps.
What Should You Do?
Assuming you're someone who migrated from Google Play Music to YouTube Music, if you mainly download tracks and listen on your smartphone, you don't need to subscribe to Premium. However, if you frequently stream on a PC and care about audio quality, I'd recommend giving Premium a try.
Also, if you want to listen to audio hosted on YouTube (like music videos or utattemita covers), keep in mind that listening on regular YouTube actually gives you better audio quality than YouTube Music—especially on a free account. Honestly, even on regular YouTube, the recommended videos and auto-generated Mix playlists are pretty good, so I don't really feel the need for YouTube Music.
Of course, setting audio quality aside, YouTube Music Premium does have some perks. You can download YouTube audio to your phone, avoid ads without needing an ad blocker, and there's a fairly solid catalog of tracks you can listen to freely (though I'm not sure how it stacks up against Spotify). For now, I'm giving YouTube Music a try for about a month.
References
On YouTube Music Audio Quality
What audio quality does YouTube Music stream? - YouTube Music Community
On Google Play Music Audio Quality
Google Play Music vs Youtube Music Audio quality - YouTube Music Community
