Reviewing Fitness Boxing 2 After Sticking With It for a Month
This article was automatically translated from Japanese by AI. Read the original Japanese version →
Table of Contents
Happy New Year! Wishing you all the best this year as well.
There are several posts I'd like to write—like my 2020 must-buys—but today I'm going to review Fitness Boxing 2, which launched in early December last year.
First, About the Original Fitness Boxing
I never properly covered it on this blog, though I did buy and play the first Fitness Boxing too.
Setting aside the finer details of the game itself—as a video game it's whatever, yet as a workout tool it was really well made and enjoyable. Starting with simple moves and gradually adding variety to ramp up the difficulty, plus providing proper practice and warm-up phases before introducing new punches, really made it shine as an exercise program.
I wear a Fitbit every day, and Fitness Boxing sessions were consistently logged as proper aerobic exercise; judging by my heart rate and such, it delivers a solid workout load. As cardio rather than strength training, I think it's a great routine.
I played every single day without fail for about a month, until I ran through all the exercise routines. Once it turned into repeating the exact same workouts, boredom hit fast and I stopped playing. Still, I thought it was a fun game, so when the sequel came out I picked it up and gave it a try.
What Changed in Fitness Boxing 2
Overall, it feels like a faithful, logical evolution of the original Fitness Boxing. A rough summary of the changes is laid out below.
Another big improvement is that the footwork steps are now shown on screen. In this game, you basically keep rhythm with constant forward-and-back steps. However, after throwing a combination like a one-two, you have to step back twice to stay on beat. The first game gave zero explanation for this, which caused a lot of confusion. In 2, they fixed that so the step cues are always displayed.
Here's what that looks like in-game.
On a personal note, being able to exclude moves with finicky motion detection like side steps from Daily Mode is huge. Missed detections used to be a major source of frustration.
Also, since I often play with my wife, being able to do Daily Mode with two players is really nice. I even bought a second set of Joy-Cons just for this.
New Problems Added
First off, the BGM song selection—or maybe the arrangements—feels less polished than in the first game. Volume levels vary quite a bit from track to track, and there are more songs with awkward rhythms to follow. As a workaround, I favorited every single track and then unfavorited the ones that are hard to stay on beat with. It seems Daily Mode defaults to picking only from your favorited songs.
Also, maybe because the new score and gauge visual effects added in 2 made things heavier to render, noticeable frame rate drops happen fairly often. Stuttering in a rhythm-based game is fatal, so I really hope they patch that. On PC games it's standard to have toggles for visual effects to deal with that sort of thing, yet at least in this game there doesn't seem to be any such option. Honestly I don't even want the score and gauge flashiness, so an option to turn those effects off would be very welcome.
Thinking of it as a sequel, the fact that hardly any new exercise routines were added is also a bit disappointing. The actual workout content is virtually identical to the original, so there's barely any reason for someone who already played a fair amount of 1 to buy 2. Even the newly added No Mercy mode just stretches out the workout duration rather than adding new move varieties. If you're deep into the original and still playing it regularly, buying 2 makes sense, whereas someone who already got tired of the first game won't find anything fresh here.
Problems Carried Over from the Original
Motion detection still has plenty of moments where it feels baffling. Hooks and uppercuts sometimes register earlier than the actual punch, while moves like weaving occasionally fail to register altogether. That said, this probably comes down to the hardware limitations of the Joy-Cons rather than the software itself. Until the hardware changes or someone invents a breakthrough method, it's probably just going to stay this way.
Also, the issue of getting bored once you've worked through all the routines hasn't changed. With running, for instance, you can aim to beat your time, whereas in Fitness Boxing it's hard to set that kind of "next goal" inside the game—all you can really do is keep going. Being a video game, getting a full month of play out of it is already great bang for the buck, yet when you look at it as an exercise tool for staying healthy, running out of fresh routines midway leaves a slightly bittersweet feeling.
Speaking of which, I've now been playing Fitness Boxing 2 for nearly a month too and have covered pretty much every routine. Since I'm right around the point where boredom usually sets in, I figured I'd write this review while my impressions are still fresh.
Summary
Fitness Boxing 2 improves on a lot of things as a proper sequel to the original. Its quality as an exercise program remains just as high, so anyone who hasn't played either entry will find it well worth picking up.
Since the core content hasn't changed much, if you never bought the first one and are curious, just start with 2. Conversely, if you've already played the original and aren't actively sticking with it right now, there's no real need to buy 2. Issues with motion detection, BGM choices, and getting bored easily due to the limited pool of routines still remain.
That's all from me—hope this helps!
